Why College Athletes Should Be Paid

Xavier Markowitz

707

College athletes work very hard and create entertainment and money for lots of people but they don’t get a cent for it. The debate over whether college athletes should get paid or not has gone on for some time but there is still no solution to the problem. Some people say that they should be paid a small salary, but other people say that they already are paid through the benefits the schools give them. Since they have no other source of income, college athletes should get a stipend, so they have enough money to live.

One of the main reasons college athletes should be paid is that they don’t have any way to make money. In the article “BCS Player Round Table: Should athletes be paid?” Notre Dame linebacker Ishaq Williams says that, “You can struggle because you don’t have time to work, to have a job.” Because the practice and games take up so much of their time, the players can’t work a job. In his article, “Why College Athletes Should be Paid,” Tyson Hartnett, an entrepreneur, writer, and former professional basketball player says that “Contrary to what all the opponents believe, being an athlete is a full-time job. On a typical day, a player will wake up before classes, get a lift or conditioning session in, go to class until 3 or 4 p.m., go to practice, go to mandatory study hall, and then finish homework or study for a test.” As you can see, the athletes have no time to have a job.

The NCAA, schools, and coaches are making millions, while the athletes don’t get a cent. Jonathan Mahler is a sports writer for the Bloomberg View. In his article, “College Athletes Should be Paid This Much,” he says that “The new College Football Playoff will be better in every way...There will be more games which means more revenue for the schools and the NCAA .The playoff series will generate on the order of 480 million a year, compared to the meager 170 million for the BCS. Everybody wins! Or, almost everybody. The athletes who are going to make college football more popular and more lucrative than it has ever been won’t earn a penny.” Mahler is saying that even though there is a new and improved system and the athletes are going to play more games than before, they are still not going to get any money for what they do.  The athletes are getting nothing from the occupation that takes up so much of their time.

Now, because they don’t have any way of making money, they take matters into their own hands. A lot of athletes have tried selling their used jerseys or autographs to fans. Chris Beck, who was a former collegiate athlete, wrote an article about college players called “College Athletes Should Get Paid: Here’s Why”. He writes about a lot of players in who tried to make money off memorabilia. One of these is A.J. Green who tried to sell one of his used game jerseys. He was suspended for four games. I think Chris Beck included this in his article because it shows that instead of helping them, the NCAA has punished the athletes for trying to put a little money in their pocket.

People arguing against college athletes being paid say that the players get endorsement for being on the team. Jeffrey Dorfman of Forbes magazine says that “they are essentially paid already because they receive free tuition, room, meal plans, some money for books...academic counseling, tutoring, life skill training, and even even nutritional advice.” Tyson Hartnett says “A $25,000 scholarship may seem like a lot of money, but it really only covers the basics. It covers thousands of dollars in mysterious, unknown university fees,... housing, a meal-plan and multiple hundred-dollar textbooks.” As you can see, most of the scholarship goes back to the school through fees they have to pay. Even though the players get pretty amazing things like academic counseling and life skill training, they are struggling to make ends meet.

The athletes should be given a stipend to compensate for what they give to the team. Tyson Hartnett agrees with me when he says that each should be paid 2,000 over the course of the semester. If the NCAA and the schools can make millions off of these kids then why can’t they? With not enough money for basic necessities, the athletes sometimes try to make some money for themselves with autographs and memorabilia. Then they get punished for just trying to get a couple bucks for laundry money. It is unfair to these kids to make them live in just over the poverty line while others make millions. College athletes should be paid so this doesn’t happen.

We just finished reading Drums, Girls, and Dangerous Pie by Jordan Sonnenblick. It is about a middle schooler named Steven Alper. Everything is normal in Steven's life, he has a little annoying brother, named Jeffery,who adores him. Like any other teenager, Steven is always focused around himself. If Jeffery tries to get some of that attention, Steven is furious. But when, *plot twist* Jeffery gets cancer, Steven has to start paying a little more attention to the little brother he had hated just a month earlier.
Steven changes drastically throughout the course of the book. He goes from self-centered moron, to a kind and openhearted young man.

When Jeffery gets made fun at school for being bald, he gets really upset. Normally Steven would be really sarcastic and say something like " Get over it,". Instead, he shaves his entire head to make Jeffery feel better. Another time Steven changes is when he is doing his big end of the year concert. Halfway through, Jeffery gets really sick and has to go to the hospital. Steven leaves his concert to accompany Jeffery to the hospital. These two examples show that Steven gave up things that were important to him in order to help Jeffery.

I think this book is trying to teach multiple lessons. Steven learns these lessons when Jeffery gets sick. I think two of these lessons are maturity and selflessness. Most teenagers are not very mature, but with only a little bit of it, conflicts can be solved easily. Selflessness is helpful in life because selflessness and kindness are linked together. You can easily make friendships if you are selfless and kind.

I am reading House of Hades by Rick Riordan. This series is about Greek and Roman myths that come to life in the modern world. At the beginning of the series the seven protagonists are given a quest. They must overcome the challenges of Greek and Roman enemies that stand in their way. Throughout all the books I saw one major theme that the author tried to say. The theme is that teamwork makes reaching goals easier.

One way the author shows the theme, is that he incorporated it into the prophecy that the protagonists have to follow. One line of it is foes bear arms at the Doors of Death. What this line means is that enemies must work together to close the Doors of Death. Another example of teamwork is when the godess Hecate and Hazel, one of main characters, have to battle a giant. They have to work together and use magic to defeat him.

Many people overlook the power of teamwork. Most teenagers do exactly that. We are inclined to try to solve problems on our own. Sometimes if a problem is too big we get frustrated. With someone helping, a little of the pressure can be taken off of our shoulders. Hazel was very stessed about the fight with the giant throughout the book. She became more confident when she learned someone was helping her.

I am reading The Snake Charmer by Jamie James. It is about Joe Slowinski who was a very intelligent snake expert. The blurb on the back says it is about his final expedition in the forests of Burma. After I was a couple chapters in I realized that the book was a biography of his life. I flipped through the book and saw that about 150 pages in, the big conflict starts. Each chapter of the book is sort of little story from a part of his life.  I chose a certain story from when he was 16.

This story is focused on the my book club's inquiry question which is, how does the character deal with and overcome the conflict in the story. When Joe is going on a special trip to dig for mammoth bones, him an his dad stop for thee night at a campsite. As his dad goes out to get Joe decides to go wildlife hunting and uncovers a rock with a rattle snake underneath it. The snake jumps up and bites him on the hand. Joe tries to get help but no one will listen. He ends up walking two miles to the nearest ranger station. I think this is a good example dealing with a conflict because how he perservered. How a person deals with a conflict is a good way to see character traits. Most people would would panic after being bitten by a snake, but Joe calmly tried to find help. This shows that he is brave. Also, after this incedent, Joe goes on to become a snake specialist, which also shows that he very brave.

This could relate to teens saying how they could become more brave. This book can show people how to keep going. Joe's has bravery and conflict sewn throughout his life story. If we are struggling with something like bullying, be brave. This book is very good at that. It shows how to deal with a conflict.

The 51st state

The people of Cheyenne Wells, Colorado gather together in a coffee shop to discuss something big, something that could change America, a 51st state. They are tired of how liberal the state of Colorado has become, and they have had enough of its Democratic leaders. Protesters in 11 rural Colorado countries have started a movement to break from Colorado and form a new state. There are many problems they have to face to accomplish this though. American history is full of states that have tried to break away from their original state, but almost none of them have succeeded.

There have been multiple attempts at creating new states. Not a lot of people hear about Absaroka or Texlahoma, but they almost became states. This is the first attempt in a long time. Most of the time states try to break away out of frustration for not getting represented. The people of Colorado are upset because of how liberal Colorado has gotten. They has to face many challenges to become a there own state. First all 11 countries have to vote to leave. Then the Colorado has to let them leave. Then Congress has to agree to admit a new state. These three steps are extremely difficult. These are the reasons that I think Colorado will not succeed at becoming a new state.

 Although Colorado probably will not become it's own state, there will be new states in the future. "It's a safe bet to say the American map is going to change in our lifetime," says Michael Trinklien. "It's sort of naive to think we're locked in at 50 and thats the end of story." Colorado's attempt is probably not going to work, but we are definitly going to see new states in the future.

I am reading Jurassic Park by Michael Crichton. When Alan Grant (A paleantologist) is called by John Hammond who is a very wealthy man. He tells Alan that he wants him to come look at his new biological preserve, in other words a zoo. Grant agrees to come for the weekend, but when he gets there he is not ready for what he sees. The animals in the park turn out to be real live dinosaurs. The park looks like it is safe, but there turn out to be many problems with it. Then the problems get to large to control and there goes from being eight velociraptors to 37 of them.

A big lesson in this book is do not try to control something you cannot contol. The owners of Jurrasic Park were so fixated on thinking they could control the dinosaurs, that they let things get to out hand before they realized the problem. When a bad storm hits the park, the power shuts down. This turns off the electric fences that hold the dinosaurs in captivity. They didn't realize that the dinosaurs were breeding either. Then there were way more animals than they previeously thought. These things show that you should not try to contol what you can't control.

This relates to humanity because sometimes we try to tackle problems that are to large and we end up wasting lots of resources and people. In Jurrasic park, the park is funded lots of money to build it, but all this money goes to waste because they are not allowed to open it to the public if it can not control the dinosaurs. If a company tries to do something that sounds really cool, for example, making dinosuars, but it is something that cannot control they will mess up and create a disaster.

I am reading the book Dead End in Norvelt by Jack Gantos. It is about a boy named Jack who just got off for summer vacation and he is going to do so much fun stuff... but then he gets grounded. Now all he's looking forward to is a summer of sitting in his room and doing chores. Then old Miss Volker calls saying she needs Jacks help. When he arrives he realizes Miss Volker needs him to write obituaries for all the original Norveltors. At first this job seems to compleatly suck, but it turns out to become pretty interesting. Maybe the summer won't be so bad for him.

Throughout the book Jack changes to realize that although he is grounded he can still have fun. One time I saw this change was when he had his birthday. He was really happy and was having fun even though he was grounded. Another time this happened was when he was talking to his best friend: "Your whole summer is wasting away,"said his best friend. "You're wrong, I'm having a very interesting summer," Jack replies. This shows that Jack likes the way his summer is going despite him being grounded. These two things show that Jack is having a good summer.

This can relate to teenagers becaues it shows that Jack found some fun even though he was grounded. If you are bored, don't just be bored. Try to find some something to do. Ideas come from boredom. Jack at first didn't do this and he was not happy, but later he realized that he could have a fun summer. At the end of the book Jack thought he had a very interesting summer.